The video explores how Barrow-in-Furness, a town in the UK, became dramatically associated with high COVID-19 cases, drawing media attention and being branded as a hot spot. This characterization led to stigmatization, impacting the community's perception by outsiders and its morale. Amidst the media frenzy, locals, medical professionals, and public health officials question the data, examine testing protocols, and address the town's geographic and social makeup, seeking to understand the real extent of COVID-19's spread in Barrow.

The examination uncovers that Barrow's apparent high COVID-19 cases might be attributed to amplified testing frequencies rather than a disproportionate outbreak. Despite the assumptions made by headlines, the town's medical facilities were not overwhelmed. The narrative invites discussions around theories connecting the virus spread to workplace practices and community behaviors but ultimately points to pre-existing health vulnerabilities as likely contributing factors to the severity of COVID-19’s impact.

Main takeaways from the video:

Please remember to turn on the CC button to view the subtitles.

Key Vocabularies and Common Phrases:

1. pariah [pəˈraɪə] - (noun) - An outcast or someone who is despised and avoided by others. - Synonyms: (outcast, undesirable, exile)

Or, to quote the Daily Mail, a pariah town.

2. cul de sac [ˈkʌl də ˌsæk] - (noun) - A street or passage closed at one end. - Synonyms: (dead end, no through road, blind alley)

The longest cul de sac in Britain, as it's affectionately known here.

3. vehemently [ˈviːəməntli] - (adverb) - In a forceful, passionate, or intense manner; with great feeling. - Synonyms: (fervently, passionately, intensely)

The problem with this theory is just that it's a theory. We didn't find any evidence for this and BAE Systems vehemently deny it.

4. moniker [ˈmɒnɪkər] - (noun) - A name or nickname. - Synonyms: (nickname, label, appellation)

There's almost nothing that we can find in the stats or the way that Barrow reacted to this pandemic that warrants that moniker.

5. inequalities [ˌɪnɪˈkwɑːlətiz] - (noun) - Differences in size, degree, circumstances, etc.; lack of equality. - Synonyms: (disparities, imbalances, disparities)

It's these health inequalities that public health officials believe makes not just barrow, but other areas that are older and poorer, more vulnerable to the illness

6. substantial [səbˈstænʃl] - (adjective) - Of considerable importance, size, or worth. - Synonyms: (considerable, sizable, significant)

And all of those things are known as substantial factors that impact on Covid-19 mortality as well.

7. discriminate [dɪˈskrɪmɪneɪt] - (verb) - To recognize a distinction; differentiate. - Synonyms: (differentiate, discern, distinguish)

What's becoming increasingly clear, though, is that Covid-19 is not indiscriminate.

8. geographic [ˌdʒiːəˈɡræfɪk] - (adjective) - Relating to the geography or topography of a specific location. - Synonyms: (spatial, territorial, topographical)

Amidst the media frenzy, locals, medical professionals, and public health officials question the data, examine testing protocols, and address the town's geographic and social makeup.

9. mortality [mɔːrˈtæləti] - (noun) - The state of being subject to death; death rate. - Synonyms: (death rate, fatality, perishability)

Here's that mortality data. 72 people have died in Barrow.

10. peninsula [pəˈnɪnsələ] - (noun) - A piece of land almost surrounded by water or projecting out into a body of water. - Synonyms: (cape, promontory, headland)

It lies on a peninsula. There's only one way into Barrow and one way out.

Coronavirus - Why has Barrow-in-Furness been hit so badly? BBC Newsnight

Barrow in Furness is a place that owes its existence to the sea, an area of heavy industry known perhaps best as the town that makes Britain's nuclear submarine. But during this Covid crisis, Barrow has become known for something darker. It has experienced Covid terribly, dreadfully, the worst hit town in the UK, according to the media, the highest number of cases in the country. Or, to quote the Daily Mail, a pariah town. We end up with a pariah town headline, but also images of Barrow being barricaded with people in white suits, turning people away. It's even caught the eye of the health secretary, Matt Hancock. I know that there's been a specific problem in terms of flare ups and in terms of the number of cases, particularly in Bowery and finesse. But can it really be the case that one town in the UK had Covid-19 so much worse than anywhere else?

In many ways, Barrow is cut off from the rest of the UK. The mountains of the lakes to the northe and the sea to the west and the south. It lies on a peninsula. There's only one way into Barrow and one way out. The longest cul de sac in Britain, as it's affectionately known here. And that geographical placement has helped to give the town a distinctive feel, a distinctive culture and community. People here talk to each other and they know that right now the town itself is being talked about. What have you heard exactly? We have a hot spot worse than anybody else in the northwest. Do you think it's a hot spot, sir? Well, yeah, according to the figures, yeah. In terms of cases per 100,000 people, Barrow has the highest number in the UK by a considerable margin.

But not everything seems to add up here. If there really was an explosion of new cases here, worse than anywhere else, you would expect the local hospital to have way more activity than anywhere else, too. But there's no evidence of that. In fact, Furness General Hospital told Newsnight that the hospital managed within capacity. Good plans in place to make sure that that didn't happen. It's something that local nurse Jennifer Culley, who treated many COVID patients, backs up herself on a day to day basis. It didn't feel like that, but that's what the statistics were telling us. What? What did it feel like? It felt. It felt strange, but it felt like normal work. It felt like we were coping and that everything was up, you know, as good as it could be at that time.

What the NHS trust did do here was test and test a lot. Newsnight has seen figures that show that Morecombe trusts have tested two and a half times more than the UK average. In fact, the director of public health here says that eight times as many over 65s have been tested in Barrow than the national average. How much is this about Barrow having tested more than other places? And how much is this about potentially, other factors? That's the million dollar question. That's what we're trying to find out at the moment. My sense is that in terms of the positive results that we're getting through, a very substantial proportion of it is about the testing regime. But that won't explain at all. And certainly when you look at the mortality data, which is also higher, you can see that it's not just about the testing regime.

Here's that mortality data. 72 people have died in Barrow. That's an average of 107 deaths per 100,000 people. The average for England and Wales is 74 per 100,000. That means that Barrow, far from being the worst in the country, isn't even the worst hit place in Cumbria, but it still puts Barrow 45% above the national average. Barrow, like many places in the UK, has been affected disproportionately badly. But why? Well, one theory here is it's to do with the housing itself. It's a bit like Coronation street, really. It's not a massive town, but everyone lives in very close proximity to each other. You know, around half the housing here is terraced housing. Hi, how are you? And that's something the MP here feels could have been a factor. So Barrow is pretty much single story, but we have high density terraced housing.

And if you look at population density, we're not unlike a large town, or even a small city in terms of that. So it makes sense that the spread has been greater because of that. Out of Barrows negative headlines has been a communal head scratch. Why us? And out of that has come speculation, some aimed at the town's biggest employer. Here's the theory doing the rounds here. Well, there's various systems and there's a lot of people that work there, isn't there? Is that something you've heard about? Yeah, I know that there's not as many people working now, but at first, the whole of the company was working, weren't they? This is a theory we heard time and time again that contractors from BAE Systems coming in from outside the town may have spread the virus.

The problem with this theory is just that it's a theory. We didn't find any evidence for this and BAE Systems vehemently deny it. It's something I asked the local mp about. Is there any evidence to suggest that BAE Systems has anything to do with Barrow's higher than average death rate? So I've spoken to the Department of Health and our director of public health in Cumbria about this, and there's nothing that they can see to suggest that big employers we have Sellafield up the road as well, have been drivers of infection. I mean, it's hard to believe that when you've got large groups of people, it won't lead to infection, but nothing to suggest it's above any national average.

What is clear is that people don't totally know what's gone on here. People don't know whether Barrow's been hit really badly or just badly. And as a result of that, people are reaching for conclusions. And BAE systems is one of those conclusions. There are other theories, too, that the people of Barrow simply didn't follow social distancing during lockdown. But I spoke to the local police here, who said they'd seen no evidence that people in Barrow followed the rules less than elsewhere. The truth is that Barrow isn't a prior town. There's almost nothing that we can find in the stats or the way that Barrow reacted to this pandemic that warrants that moniker.

But some of the clues as to why it has a higher death rate than others can almost certainly be found in the character of the town itself, its public health profile. Barrow has a greater level of obesity than the England and Wales average, for example. And things like life expectancy are lower here, too. Three years lower for men and two for women. It's these health inequalities that public health officials believe makes not just barrow, but other areas that are older and poorer, more vulnerable to the illness. Even before Covid-19, Barrow has some of the lowest life expectancy in Cumbria.

It's got high rates of smoking, it's got high rates of heart disease, it's got relatively high rates of obesity. And all of those things are known as substantial factors that impact on Covid-19 mortality as well. So in many ways, you would expect to see a higher rate of mortality in Barrow than in many other parts of the country. That doesn't mean it's okay. Of course, it still shows that Barrow has got these substantial challenges and it's incumbent on us in public health to work with that and to try and do something about it.

So can Barrow get back to its feet? We're in lockdown, so it's a bit of a mess. Not a problem. Not a problem. Do you want to come through? Yeah, we'll just want you to socially distance, that's all. But Phil Simpson is looking to open his pub as soon as he can. So talk me through this. So how many people can be at the bar? Nobody. So the bar is going to be a no go zone. You will order from the table.

And he's optimistic about the future. People that aren't going to come out will be compensated by the. By the fact that we've got less space. So I'm quite positive. I think we'll be okay. I think once we're up and running, it will be back to business as normal pretty quickly. Just different. A different normal. And people will find it weird for a while and then it's not weird anymore. And that's my hope.

But Barrow now has its own specific problems in getting back to normal. Does it make it even more challenging when Barrow's been sort of labeled the black spot of Britain in terms of Covid-19 so I don't think it makes the recovery more difficult. I think what it makes challenging is getting children back to school, people back to work, because there's that fear in the back of people's minds. They're worried that actually there is something there. There's something that's not understood and that they're putting themselves, they're putting their families, putting their businesses at risk by stepping out from their homes. That's the real problem in many ways.

There's still much we don't understand about COVID Imperfect data can lead to places like Barrow being unfairly singled out. What's becoming increasingly clear, though, is that Covid-19 is not indiscriminate. That's part of the cruelty of this virus. It hits vulnerable places harder than it does others. Far from being exceptional, Barrow's story is in fact a depressingly common tale up and down the country of health inequalities made starker still by this pandemic.

Covid-19, Barrow-In-Furness, Health Inequalities, Science, Global, Technology, Bbc Newsnight